#17: concerned - Do NOT support this campaign !! 

Your concerns are justified, and should be born in mind for any further stocking activity. As a starting point, all stocking efforts must use progeny taken from the Wye. However, in accordance with your arguement, genetically inferior fish produced from man-made efforts [using native progeny] are unlikely to survive or come to dominate the genetics of a river system. If they do, they presumably must have genetic traits which favour survival and therefore, are genetically suited to the river system. If they don't, their genetics will die out. 

If the genetic pool is taken from the river system, then the integrity of the genetics will be maintained. For every egg produced by man-made efforts in this way, the potential for genetic improvement is increased, as it is only through replication that modification and enhancement of genetic traits may increase.

No replication, no diversification. And that is what we currently have on the Wye; a declining gene pool in need of drastic action.

#35: - Re: Do NOT support this campaign !! 

 All suplimentary stocking of the River Wye, HAS been with Wye indigenouse Salmon over recent decades, as far as we're aware!  Otherwise EA/NRW wouldn't have approved stocking them!! In answer to Guest 35.